Zoom Logo

D4EU - Shared screen with speaker view
Richard Langworthy
36:53
Can we please have stalls in Kent too?
Natasja Dumay
39:15
What can we do to stop the government from using covid etc as justification for problems experienced by the UK only (not our neighbouring countries) which must surely be down to Brexit? How do we hold them to account?
Natasja Dumay
39:30
ps I'm one of those Europeans
Alan Rankin
41:51
Q Will a United Ireland and an Independent Scotland precede any application for little England to join the EU?
Joseph Heaven
42:51
Q. How will EM reset beliefs about the EU in the U.K.?Once we humans have established our views, and perhaps even articulated them (e.g. through a vote), it is cognitively difficult to change our beliefs.
Mark Cartwright
42:59
Q The Unite Union has apparently voted to oppose FPTP. How big an impetuous will this give Labour and an opposition progressive alliance to remove the Tories - and thus (hopefully) a first step to rejoin the EU ?
Stephen Stacey
44:14
Good QQ coming in. Will try to get them answered by AA.
Natasja Dumay
44:44
Q: does the fact that the EU have agreed to minimise paperwork mean we're working towards re-entering the customs union?
Alex Barlow
46:19
Q; Why isn't the Labour front bench pointing out that Brexit is ruining the UK? They should lead rather than hoping not to upset Brexit people.
Joseph Heaven
46:20
Q. Could you please explain the difference between the customs union and the single market. (AA said to re-enter the CU first, then the SM).
Francis Deas
46:35
Will Europe have us back?
Peter
46:43
Q. Andrew.Surely the first step is to rejoin the Single Market and Customs Union A La Norway. No way will Boris J admit openly that Brexit isn't working, but does that really matter for now?
Michael Harper
47:05
Q: how do we rebrand ourselves? We need a new logo…
Natasja Dumay
47:09
Q: so many people around me believe the government rhetoric re reasons for issues at hand. How do you change those people's minds without making them feel we're remoaners?
Richard Langworthy
50:05
I hope we can also save the NHS in the process!
Natasja Dumay
51:12
Hear hear!! they no doubt have private healthcare contracts drafted, ready for signing once the NHS falls over (and I work there)
john row
51:16
Q What plans are there to pressure a change for musicians touring Europe.
macuser
51:58
14.000 members is the same as the Airedale terrier society.
Richard Jackman
52:13
Q: AA says that polls say that the majority of the British Public feel that Brexit was a mistake. Which polls? Commissioned by whom?
Mark Cartwright
52:47
Q Do we need to join pro EU and pro NHS etc folk together as part of the movement ?
ADONIS
52:53
I agree that 14,000 is far too few members for the European Movement. So let's all join up our ten best friends and closest relations!
Richard Langworthy
53:50
Starmer is also a jerk! We need either Lewis, Trickett, Butler or McDonnell to replace him!
macuser
53:55
How can we cut through the “over it’ attitude? face masks anyone?
Michael Laycock
54:20
Even Mail on Sunday published their poll in which majority of MAIL readers thought Brexit was a mistake. But that doesn't mean they want to rejoin so we must take it step by step.
Michael Harper
55:05
Can EM think realistically it can replace a set of opposition parties who are NOT talking about Brexit not working?
Natasja Dumay
55:12
Q: how do you stop the EU being blamed for it not working, insinuating that they're just being difficult?
Mark Cartwright
55:27
We need to convert brexiters and waverers .. pick 5 people each and convert them!
Natasja Dumay
55:47
if only if it was that easy
Natasja Dumay
55:53
I've tried
Joseph Heaven
56:11
Q. (How) Will the existence of trade treaties enacted between the U.K. and non-EU members since brexit complicate re-entry into the CU and/or SM?
Natasja Dumay
56:12
I sincerely wonder how we engage and convince those people.....
Natasja Dumay
56:25
bbc is led by Conservative chairman now....
MJP
56:47
Hi Andrew. Martin here - your undistinguished former tutee! During the talk. I have joined the European Movement - so that's 14,001 at least! As a Head teacher, at least here in Cambridge, the overwhelming majority of young people (teenagers) regard Brexit (rightly) as a terrible mistake. There is young energy ready to get behind the movement if we can mobilise them. At the moment I think that many feel fatalistic on the most important issues to them (Brexit, the environment).
Michael Laycock
58:52
I agree. How can we motivate the young to join us and become active?
Mark Cartwright
59:42
Q How do we get a bigger voice within the MsM ? How do we tackle the BBC - who are deliberately omitting the B word ?
Joseph Heaven
59:46
Q. Will the EM campaign exclusively on economic arguments, or are there cultural and/or geopolitical arguments that will resonate with the U.K. population? What about conceptions of sovereignty & independence and sovereignty & cooperation?
Natasja Dumay
59:50
I do know from Twitter that there are many angry people out there with the current government (covid, brexit, etc) who really don't know what they can do to change it.
Ted Richards
59:53
Q - I am no expert in slogans but I don't feel that "Brexit isn't working" is very catchy. In particular, it will not appeal to those who thrive on soundbites. Who is advising the European Movement on PR?
Neil Sutherland
01:03:38
Yes please to the Progressive Alliance!
Richard Jackman
01:03:54
Q: Can AA please describe his ‘sunny uplands’. Once we re-engaged with Europe, how would we want to shape it?
Natasja Dumay
01:04:27
John Glenn is yet to support me on ANYTHING I've asked him to represent me on. He doesn't care as he knows his seat is solid...
Michael Harper
01:05:22
How is EM reaching out to important business and community leaders ref. Brexit isn’t working?
Natasja Dumay
01:05:25
Q: and how can we campaign with the government making legal changes to our ability to protest etc?
Natasja Dumay
01:05:42
I feel like I'm stuck in a George Orwell novel....
Mark Cartwright
01:07:13
Labour is almost certainly pro EU ! But this doesn't need to be shouted from the rooftops. All of here will vote to rejoin. I anticipate both Lab and Cons are chasing 40 seats in the red wall. I imagine timing is crucial !
macuser
01:08:37
Advertise the European movement! Even I haven’t heard of it.
Peter
01:09:27
Labour's Left see the EU as a Rich Man's Club and in an economic sense they are probably right. But the Bankers, etc. in the EU can be made to pursue different actions!
Sue Jones Whiteparish
01:11:44
Ian Wright (Food & Drink Alliance) is highly vocal - and in private unprintable!
Peter
01:13:17
Taking people with you doesn't mean that they initially share your point of view. It means that they trust you.
Natasja Dumay
01:13:43
I agree with @mark cartwright that we need to join pro EU and pro NHS etc folk together as part of the movement.
Natasja Dumay
01:14:31
and an economy that works for the environment!!
Mark Cartwright
01:15:29
Q I am hearing that Govt are laying down plans to dismantle the constitutional legal framework of the UK e.g. issues that the Supreme Court can deal with. How long have we got ?
Natasja Dumay
01:16:37
Yes and I've seen an article statement that Dominic Raab wants to make legal changes so they can intervene with legal judgments if they disagree!!
Michael Harper
01:18:05
Can we have some new EM T-Shirts for the new catchphrase “Brexit isn’t working”!
ADONIS
01:18:42
Yes we need those T shirts!! How about some with the Wiltshire logo on too?
Peter Battrick
01:19:21
Regarding messaging. Do we have a Speakers Panel that we can call on if we as individuals can drum up enough support for local, village hall meetings?
Peter
01:19:29
Taking peopled with you - the reforming Labour govt. of the sixties understood very well that their reforms of legalising homosexuality, legalising abortion, tackling racism, etc. wold never pass a referendum, but they could be introduced and people's views would change over time. Similarly Brexiteer views.
Richard Jackman
01:19:45
I’ve joined the EM and volunteered! Yes Yes Yes to Kate’s push to arm us with good data so that we can win arguments with sound facts rather than subjective views.
Kate Freeman
01:20:57
Can you all help us on 20th November action day?
Michael Harper
01:21:00
We need an agreed colour scheme..
Michael Laycock
01:21:17
Q. What does Andrew think of us continuing to use EU/Council of Europe flags et the like?
Natasja Dumay
01:21:40
Q: before printing slogans on tshirts, wouldn't it first be better to work out what slogan is the most engaging slogan to those people most likely to come on board?
Stephen Stacey
01:22:39
Fee questions coming up. Raise your hands if you have a Q not already asked and answered!
Sue Jones Whiteparish
01:22:40
There were some very prescient cartoons from the German and Thai press about Brexit in The European - pity they aren’t made far more public (bit like Led by Donkeys billboards)
David Davidge
01:24:44
Marples must go was a wonderful car sticker. Where is our ‘ Brexit isn’t working’ sticker
Michael Laycock
01:25:12
Q. What does Andrew think of us continuing to use EU/Council of Europe flags et the like?
Joseph Heaven
01:25:21
This is a long question...
Mark Cartwright
01:26:09
Any campaign group needs to be 'credible' in the eyes of ordinary people.
Neil Sutherland
01:26:41
Just joined the European Movement ….
Michael Harper
01:26:46
I am sure lots of EM members have stories about trading problems affecting them personally since Brexit was done.
Mark Cartwright
01:28:46
3 near neighbours have ceased trading with the EU - 1 has moved abroad to work in the EU. How are these people being counted ?
Richard Langworthy
01:29:30
Question: can we please run adverts for our movement, similar to aussie activist group GetUp! ?
ADONIS
01:30:31
https://www.europeanmovement.co.uk/monthly_membership
Di Harris
01:30:59
Sadly, the Labour Remain activist training was rubbish
Mark Cartwright
01:31:28
Can we get Led By Donkeys the Good Law Project et al to join forces ?
Anna Beria
01:33:45
Give them hope!
Michael Harper
01:33:46
Us older ones can still find time to motivate younger family members..
Anna Beria
01:34:03
You have to believe that it is possible.
Catherine Dawson CCL-UK
01:34:09
I couldn't cope with the personal abuse hurled at us.
Ted Richards
01:35:28
Who hasn't hear of Tic Tok!!!
Anna Beria
01:36:06
@Ted: Heard of, but not used.
macuser
01:36:09
Signed-up to EM. - Thank you!
Natasja Dumay
01:36:34
As an EU citizen I've been told to f off back to my own country more than once (by complete strangers) - incl whilst being threatened with a knife. So I'm a lot more careful trying to get others around me onboard
Steve Rouse
01:38:11
Tick tock is very 'Youth'
Richard Langworthy
01:38:31
U froze
Catherine Dawson CCL-UK
01:38:46
I've also been told by my brother that my politics make him sick i no longer talk to him can't cope with the abuse.
Natasja Dumay
01:39:12
I've lost friends myself....
Natasja Dumay
01:39:32
Hence my question re messaging and engagement
Mark Cartwright
01:40:00
There are some people who will never be converted. Concentrate on the waverers ?
Natasja Dumay
01:40:02
And I think tying the issue to the survival of the NHS would really help.
Mark Cartwright
01:41:18
Agree with Natasja ! The NHS is a powerful motivator
Catherine Dawson CCL-UK
01:41:19
Personally i would prefer we followed the French or German model more people would survive cancer for a start.
Natasja Dumay
01:43:16
Well I can tell you if we privatise the NHS, individual contributions would double at best. My elderly parents on a basic pension in the Netherlands have to choose a new policy each year and decide whether they inxmclude Physiotherapy, Orthotics etc etc.
Natasja Dumay
01:43:42
Because then there will need to be a profit margin too.
Anna Beria
01:43:52
I think that much will depend on what happens in the EU over the next few years. If they can open up, listen to people, perhaps reform some of their modus operandi and be - not only appear - to be more willing to accommodate different forms of membership, it might be easier to convince the wider public that rejoining is in this country's interest.
Michael Harper
01:44:07
Q: shouldn’t the EM put a conference on Improving Britain (devolution, regional development etc.)
Natasja Dumay
01:44:48
And the way the care profession is a profession in other European countries, for which you obtain a professional qualification. Not a job basically anyone could do.
Natasja Dumay
01:46:39
hear hear
macuser
01:47:51
Thank you for inspiration and hope. L Adonis.
peter martindale
01:47:58
Thank you Andrew. I have really enjoyed this!
Richard Jackman
01:48:03
Excellent talk. Thank you.
Brian Sadler
01:48:18
Well done everyone!
Michael Laycock
01:48:22
Thxs Andrew..very inspiring
Tim Evans (Cumbria)
01:48:31
Thanks you
Mark Cartwright
01:48:49
Thanks Andrew - v inspiring
Catherine Dawson CCL-UK
01:48:52
Thanks, making me slightly more hopeful
Peter
01:48:55
Excellent talk and questions. Thank you all
Hilary Wilkey
01:49:01
Excellent talk. Thank you all!
Joanna Minchin
01:49:26
Thank you from the Isle of Wight
Neil Sutherland
01:49:26
Thank you all!
Di Harris
01:49:44
Leave came together, but was very different groups - the far left hate Brussels, some hate immigration, others had other reasons for voting Leave. When I speak to them they don’t agree with others. But they all voted Leave.
Joseph Heaven
01:49:57
Thank you!
Mark Cartwright
01:50:15
Thanks for organising
Steve Rouse
01:50:24
Thanks to the team at Devizes for Europe!