Zoom Logo

ISRAELI PALESTINIAN PEACE SIMULATION - Shared screen with speaker view
buyestate@aol.com
19:24
The Israeli government will not allow it. So save your breath. This is just another way to say peace and buy more time as usual to continue the brutal occupation. No justice no peace. You need to focus on working on human rights for all.
Juergen Rose
28:42
designate me Pal.
John Collier
29:23
Please represent me as Pal
Naseer- PA President
29:39
Click on the three dots next to the "UNMUTE" button and you can rename
Naseer- PA President
29:57
In your video box
Mazin Qumsiyeh
31:17
this is not right. I was here to hear Gideon. your facts and assumptions are wrong. further the whole premise is wrong. the diagnosis here is important.. it is simply coloniasm
Mazin Qumsiyeh
37:49
email me if you are interested in the only possible future. based on human rights and not gimmicks mazin@qumsiyeh.org
buyestate@aol.com
47:15
How do you propose to implement justice for all???
Ray Hanania
55:51
Everyone is entitled tot heir opinion nd I applaud Josef for respecting that principle and working with the majority not individuals
buyestate@aol.com
01:00:09
Gideon is the only one that is making sense and understands the horrible situation! Don’t you think you should listen to him more?
PA-Claire Bacha
01:00:27
Brilliant, Gideon.
PA-Claire Bacha
01:01:11
Will need a lot of truth and conciliation!
Tanya
01:02:29
Yes Gideon!! Well said
PA-Claire Bacha
01:02:30
I think that truth and conciliation will be very difficult.
PA-Claire Bacha
01:04:02
The truth will emerge from dialogue. We will need to teach dialogue.
Todd
01:06:11
No
buyestate@aol.com
01:07:52
Will Israeli history include the wiping out 465 Palestinian villages
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:09:06
Justice first. Stepping stones are needed.
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:11:29
Thank you, Mr Israeli President.
PA Johan van der Merwe
01:11:56
Why would the Israeli government accept the legitimacy of the Confederation? Why would it not much rather just ignore it? And is it not rather strange to have an idealistic body, a little dwarf, as the Confederation to confer veto power to the 2 governments,? Would one not rather expect power to be conferred from the major to a minor role player. Cf. the United Nations.
PA-Claire Bacha
01:14:12
Workers control and cooperatives?
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:15:46
Well said Gideon. The inequality must be addressed.
PA-Claire Bacha
01:18:07
Do we all give up right of return?
Tanya
01:18:12
The right of return should work for all.
Tanya
01:18:31
Not only for jews
PA-Claire Bacha
01:18:53
What if Jews give up right of return?
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:19:09
RIght of return for all.
buyestate@aol.com
01:21:09
Why did Jews wait more than 2000 years to want right of return when Palestinians don’t have the right of return after 1948???
PA-Claire Bacha
01:27:57
A lot depends on the diaspora. What can we do in the diaspora?
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:29:07
Gideon, I 100% agree.
President PA- Naseer
01:29:35
Yep, 100%
PA-Claire Bacha
01:30:00
Me too. What can we do?
charlesfredricks
01:32:24
And 972
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:33:45
Palestinians need justice, not relationships.
PA-Kathy Shapiro
01:33:54
Love that question/comment, Libby!
PA-Kathy Shapiro
01:36:29
I hear you, Deirdre, and agree. Yet wouldn’t relationships in addition (not instead of) be a help to this situation?
PA-Kathy Shapiro
01:38:21
I believed the Jewish narratives I was raised with until I got to know Palestinians and heard their experiences.
PA Libby T. San Mateo CA
01:39:04
if you don't see everyone as human and equal it is easy to pose enemies and continue with the daily violence and fear of the other relationship is key to bringing about change and giving conscent to equal rights
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:40:18
Violence is not coming from Palestinian people.
PA Libby T. San Mateo CA
01:41:03
The charter changed years ago that is an old excuse
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:41:07
That charter changed in 2017!! Hi
Ray Hanania
01:41:29
Both sides hav extremists advocating killing reach other … you can’t say one side is and the other side is not. That’s the kind of logic we have to get away from
PA-Claire Bacha
01:41:52
The fear creates the violence, I think. It is not the product of the violence.
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:42:44
No comparison.
PA-Claire Bacha
01:43:02
I agree about the imbalance.
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:44:55
Hamas is a resistance Movement
Michael Waterman
01:45:17
From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be free. Does this mean that the Jews can just live in the Mediterranean? We have seen the Jews evicted from all Arab lands. Will this happen again if Israel is "removed" as a Jewish State, as is being suggested by some of the speakers?
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:46:15
What did you say to Hitler when he was occupying Europe?
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:47:09
Jews need to stand with Palestinians against Zionism.
Michael Waterman
01:47:36
The world didn't say anything as he demeaned and killed Jews. It was only when he went after the other Europeans that they began to fight him. It's obviously okay to hate Jews.
PA Deirdre Tighe
01:47:44
AreThe Palestinians to blame for that too?
Michael Waterman
01:49:31
There were no "Arab" Palestinians at the time of WW2. Actually, references to Palestinians at that time, only was used about Jews living in that area.
Michael Waterman
01:49:53
The leaders of the Arabs actually supported the Nazis.
Ray Hanania
01:51:07
Josef, Gideon, everyone … I must leave but THANK YOU for the sane and respectful discussion
buyestate@aol.com
01:54:43
The Jews were welcomed to Palestine in the 40’s, why are Jews in denial about Palestine? Jews were less than 10% of the population in Palestine at that time.
buyestate@aol.com
01:56:58
Why don’t we focus on human rights for all? There are fanatics on both sides so do not focus on one side, it is not productive, don’t you think?
buyestate@aol.com
01:58:28
“They were promised the Sea” is a movie everyone should see, produced by a Moroccan Jew.
PA - George Rupp
02:02:26
i'm leaving, Josef. I cannot accept that lies pass uncontested. If you don'y give me the opportunity to rebut those lies, I refuse to conbtinue here. Bye and good luck.
Naseer
02:03:05
You made a good point and it was heard George. Stick around
buyestate@aol.com
02:04:34
No justice No peace.
charlesfredricks
02:04:38
To Gideon’s point that the solution must come from the diaspora, the political status quo in favor of right wing Israeli policies is crumbling: view the video journal of the New York Times on the recent Gaza attack and investigation of Israeli govt claims
PA Deirdre Tighe
02:05:29
Palestinian people expelled no one.
PA Libby T. San Mateo CA
02:09:03
Covid and climate crisis show we are all connected and interdependent and must learn how to cooperate and live together assuring survival fof ALL