Zoom Logo

TOPA Town Hall - Shared screen with speaker view
Elise, New Economy Project
01:05:57
Hi everyone! we're going to get started in just a few minutes!
Interpreter Ruben Martinez
01:06:33
Hello, would you like for the interpreters to make an announcement about interpretation before being assigned as interpreters?
Marcela Mitaynes
01:07:07
Hi everyone, excited to share this space with you all. I am Assembly member Marcela Mitaynes
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
01:10:42
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
Samuel Stein
01:10:42
Hi everyone -- this is Sam Stein from Community Service Society
JACKY WONG
01:10:43
Jacky Wong -- Chinatown CLT, Chinese interpreter
Debra Ack
01:10:46
Debra - ENY CLT
Hannah Anousheh
01:10:48
Hannah Anousheh (she/her), East New York CLT
Sam Gordon
01:10:51
Sak
Lisle Coleman
01:10:52
Lisle Coleman, City-wide Tenant Union of Rochester
Arielle Hersh
01:10:53
welcome! good to be here with you all - Arielle she/they at UHAB
Steve Herrick
01:10:54
Hi, Steve Herrick, from Cooper Square Committee
Laura Sewell
01:10:55
Laura Sewell, East Village Community Coalition
John Krinsky
01:10:58
John Krinsky NYCCLI he/him
Julia Duranti-Martinez, EHEBCLT, she/her
01:11:00
Julia, she/her, East Harlem El Barrio CLT
jacob Levenson
01:11:02
Jacob Levenson: DSA Member and new to this group.
Sam Gordon
01:11:05
Sam (he), Resource Generation, Flatbush, Brooklyn
Tanya Dwyer
01:11:11
Tanya Dwyer (she/her) Parish House @TPDwyerEsq
Francis Stallings
01:11:15
Francis Brooklyn
Interpreter Ruben Martinez
01:11:23
I can't because I'm in interpretation room
Athena Bernkopf
01:11:34
Hey yall, Athena (they/them), East Harlem El Barrio CLT
Carlos Ronisky
01:11:35
Carlos Ronisky he/him 209 East 25th St. Tenants Assoc./Cooper Sq Committee
Kenya Mccall
01:11:37
Kenya McCall ENY CLT
Sabrina Bazile (they/sabrina)
01:11:39
Sabrina Bazile, they/sabrina - Black Homeownership Project, Center for NYC Neighborhoods
Patrice Edwards
01:11:51
Patrice (she/they), Bronx Community Land Trust
Gabriela Sandoval Requena
01:11:53
Hello, this is Gabriela at New Destiny Housing
Gary Simon
01:11:54
Gary Simon, 120 E.19th St Tenant's Association
Claudia Waterton
01:12:04
Claudia, Co Tenant Lead in the Bronx
Monique Roberts
01:12:15
Monique Roberts, HOPE BK
Nico Smit
01:12:18
Nico Smit 510 e 6th ta member
Deyanira Del Rio
01:12:26
Dey (she/her), New Economy Project + NYCCLI
Emma Colley
01:12:30
Hi everyone my name is Emma (she/her) I'm a Brooklyn resident and urban planning graduate student.
Catherine Murcek
01:13:06
Catherine Murcek, she/her, NYC Network of Worker Cooperatives
Alex Yong
01:13:16
hi I'm Alex [he/they] from WSNA (the West Side Neighborhood Alliance)
Ruth Lopez.She/her. NYCNOWC. PA'LANTE
01:13:16
Ruth López Martínez. She/her. NYCNOWC. PA'LANTE CO-OP. Queens
Lisle Coleman
01:13:47
decision making power in one’s housing
Carlos Ronisky
01:13:51
Ownership
Samuel Stein
01:13:53
Residents have the say over the future of their housing, not just landlords
Arielle Hersh
01:13:54
no more landlords!
Catherine Murcek
01:13:55
residents of a building have voting power on issues relating to their building
jacob Levenson
01:13:55
Resident of a building owning and running the property they share with other resident of the building.
Wasim Lone
01:13:59
no more landlords
Debra Ack
01:13:59
Our land, our community, our building, our decision
Tanya Dwyer
01:14:04
Ownership of real estate or a controlling vote of decisions
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
01:14:20
Ownership after 20 years of living
Michelle Nguyen
01:14:20
residents in control!
Francis Stallings
01:14:20
owning your home or cooperatively owning it
Gary Simon
01:14:56
Tenants having more control over their living environments.
Elizabeth Ruiz
01:15:12
Elizabeth ruiz NYCNOWC PROGRESSIVE CLEANING
Lisle Coleman
01:20:07
incredible
Catherine Murcek
01:20:10
++++++
Catherine Murcek
01:20:36
Sorry, DCR=?
Francis Stallings
01:20:36
what 2019 law?
Arielle Hersh
01:20:48
HSTPA! rent law protections
Samuel Stein
01:20:49
Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019
Lisle Coleman
01:21:00
congratulations!!
Samuel Stein
01:21:06
DHCR = Division of Homes and Community Renewal
Francis Stallings
01:21:15
can explain specifically how that law lead to the purchase?
Catherine Murcek
01:22:06
So impressed by you all!! / muy impresionado por ustedes!
w watson
01:22:08
Who represented you?
Samuel Stein
01:22:52
Francis: I believe Claudia is saying that the increased tenant protections that came from HSTPA and their ongoing case with DHCR meant that speculators didn't want to buy their building because they didn't think they'd be able to raise the rents, evict the tenants and make a big profit.
Francis Stallings
01:23:19
k thanks
Sabrina Bazile (they/sabrina | black homeownership project)
01:23:49
DHCR = Division of Homes and Community Renewal
Carlos Ronisky
01:24:25
Can you repeat that tenant organization
Elise, New Economy Project
01:24:40
Flatbush Tenant Coalition
Carlos Ronisky
01:24:45
Thx
Kenya Mccall
01:25:14
Gary can you please provide the name of the legal firm that provided pro-bono services
Elise, New Economy Project
01:25:22
Flatbush Tenant Coalition
Elise, New Economy Project
01:25:37
is the tenant organizing group that Gary started working with in his building
Kenya Mccall
01:25:56
Thank you Elise
w watson
01:29:12
The landlord is unwilling to sell, is there a way to force the sale?
Samuel Stein
01:30:56
W Watson: Not exactly. But often if/when the city or state cracks down on bad landlord behavior -- overcharges, building code violations, harassment, etc. -- the landlord will get fed up and want to sell. Then, if we pass TOPA, tenants can potentially take control.
w watson
01:31:31
Thx Samuel stein
Kenya Mccall
01:32:26
I am so grateful to be on this call. I am a condo owner in a small building in East New York. This is an affordable housing condo building...lottery. I need to connect with an organization that can help the owners understand they are owners not renters and mustb pay into the building. We need legal assistance to work with the owners to pay their maintenance. If we do not turn the building around I can see we will lose this building to speculators and the owners will not be able to afford the going rate for rents.
INTERPRETE(R). Flor Lopez (she/ella,her)
01:36:47
Please slow down
w watson
01:41:01
Who was the attorney?
Lisle Coleman
01:41:18
++++
Monique Roberts
01:41:22
++++
Arielle Hersh
01:41:40
+++
Osvaldo Nunez
01:41:47
💥💥
Sabrina Bazile (they/sabrina | black homeownership project)
01:44:58
+++++
Carlos Ronisky
01:45:59
What is stack?
Catherine Murcek
01:45:59
stack
Catherine Murcek
01:47:56
That makes sense, thank you! / Tiene sentido, gracias!
Catherine Murcek
01:49:03
👍
Alex Yong
01:49:18
stack is like a line or queue. the last person to say "stack" is the end of the line/queue
Sabrina Bazile (they/sabrina | black homeownership project)
01:52:13
like why would landlords sell to tenants?
Gary Simon
01:52:31
Kenya, the name of the legal firm is Brooklyn Legal Services, Inc.
a wilson
01:52:40
What is the fee that UHAB is charging for services to the tenants at 100 134 St in the Bronx ?
Gary Simon
01:53:14
Elise, yes, our Tenant's Association is within our building.
Samuel Stein
01:53:48
Tenants can nominate a non-profit of their choice (or, I think, the public housing authority) if they can't/don't want to buy it.
Thomas Abbot
01:54:07
Stack
Evy Viruet
01:54:12
Most tenants have section 8 - Good questions.
Elise, New Economy Project
01:54:26
Thanks Deborah, we agree with you!
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
01:55:01
Thanks Elise for this very informative session
Evy Viruet
01:56:26
There are buildings that have the 70-30 - Depending on your income.
John Krinsky
01:57:44
Can a limited equity coop have coop owned units with a non-eviction conversion plan?
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
01:57:46
If someone can't afford to pay the rent is there a rent subsidy program for those renters who want to stay but can't afford commitment.
Samuel Stein
01:57:56
You can have renters in a limited-equity coop, though. But the tenants can also nominate a qualified purchaser to buy.
Anna Vincenty
01:58:14
In other words every tenant would have to purchase their apartments..
Arielle Hersh
01:58:35
Yes, usually the threshold is 80% of units need to be owners in an HDFC co-op
Samuel Stein
01:58:59
Deborah, there are some rental assistance programs out there already, but we're also pushing for something called the Housing Access Voucher Program, which could help tenants afford to stay in their buildings for the long term.
Valerio Orselli- TLIO CLT
01:59:09
There is bill pending in NYS Senate to provide funds fire CLT to acquire property. Sponsored y Sen Kavanaugh (S3265). We need to support it as well as TOPA.
Francis Stallings
02:00:24
stack
Elise, New Economy Project
02:01:08
organize!!
Julia Duranti-Martinez, EHEBCLT, she/her
02:01:13
^^^
Arielle Hersh
02:01:14
organizing works!
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
02:01:33
I see a lot of building in the area under HDFC and they are surviving, depending on the number of apartments
Michelle Nguyen
02:01:47
I appreciate that this call gives me a good understanding of the organizing that does/would need to be done with TOPA
Alex Yong
02:01:53
Thanks Valerio. I think it's S8265 https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2021/s8265
Thomas Abbot
02:02:16
stack
Valerio Orselli- TLIO CLT
02:02:29
Yes. Thank you for correction.
a wilson
02:03:01
stack with question on TOPA
Elise, New Economy Project
02:03:06
7A is a great organizing tool!
Michelle Nguyen
02:04:13
very informative!
Anna Vincenty
02:04:27
What exactly is a 7A building??
Elise, New Economy Project
02:04:51
7A is when a court appoints an administer to collect rents and do repairs
Michelle Nguyen
02:04:54
https://www1.nyc.gov/site/hpd/services-and-information/7a-program.page
Chelle BloomXX
02:05:13
He, the 7A , hasn't been that great. There are many problems in the building.
Evy Viruet
02:05:43
That’s why you all have to get together and form a Tenant Association.
Chelle BloomXX
02:06:22
A lot of traffic all hours. 7A is on that payroll.
Alex Yong
02:07:26
here's the most informative YouTube I've seen about 7A proceedings https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nRJvBex1LAA#t=29m34s It is from "Housing Court Answers" and it's fabulous. You will find yourself taking notes
Chelle BloomXX
02:07:56
Thank you
Evy Viruet
02:08:14
Cooper Square is a great organization
Elise, New Economy Project
02:08:15
A. Wilson and Frances Stallings are also on stack
Elise, New Economy Project
02:09:11
"Right to a fair appraisal"
Justin Perkins (Sen. Myrie)
02:09:21
YESSS
Lisle Coleman
02:09:57
Francis went!
Evy Viruet
02:10:18
Thanks
Lucy M
02:11:05
Thankyou everyone!
Anna Vincenty
02:11:13
if you have lots of tenants that are on a fixed income how are they helped so that they to can partake in being able to purchase their apartments?
Elise, New Economy Project
02:11:37
Call your state elected and let them know we want to pass TOPA! https://p2a.co/h237vuk
Sabrina Bazile (they/sabrina | black homeownership project)
02:12:17
++++
Julia Duranti-Martinez, EHEBCLT, she/her
02:12:31
We also have to win financing for TOPA, Anna. The idea is that tenants would get outside financing to purchase their building and make needed repairs. Also funding for organizing and technical assistance!
Anna Vincenty
02:13:22
Thank you Julia..
Elise, New Economy Project
02:13:55
Info about Claudia's building!: https://www.uhab.org/bronx-tenants-take-steps-towards-homeownership-in-historic-purchase/
w watson
02:15:49
stack
Evy Viruet
02:16:17
I got you W. Watson
M.E. Greene-Cohen
02:17:27
what role will sponsor/developers have in this program to create profit for themselves ?
Carlos Ronisky
02:17:28
TOPA can certainly spark interest in at least participating in the Tenant Association
Francis Stallings
02:18:19
lol that dog
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
02:18:25
TOPA is a means to an end for so many tenants, we are tired of living in a city with no ownership. Thank you for having this sessions, it was very informative.
Chelle BloomXX
02:19:59
How can I obtain a copy of this recording?
Elise, New Economy Project
02:20:23
We will send it out to those who registered
Elise, New Economy Project
02:21:12
We are researching financing of TOPA deals in other cities, which may include banks but also include CDFIs and other community-focused lenders, as well as city/state money.
Elise, New Economy Project
02:22:24
call elected officials!: https://p2a.co/h237vuk
Valerio Orselli- TLIO CLT
02:22:28
Cooper Square Committee is actively organizing Croman tenants -(212) 228-8210
Marcela Mitaynes
02:22:40
Call your senator. assembly member and the govenor
Elise, New Economy Project
02:22:41
join us Friday to celebrate Claudia!!!! https://www.uhab.org/bronx-tenants-take-steps-towards-homeownership-in-historic-purchase/
Arielle Hersh
02:22:47
Meet in front of 700 E 134th St in the Bronx at 3:30pm!
Arielle Hersh
02:23:06
On Friday!
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
02:23:30
Please make sure that if tenants cant buy there building, landlords should not be able to sell over and over without any recourse. Regentrification has now made it impossible for us to be a part of this program.
Elise, New Economy Project
02:24:04
elise@neweconomynyc.org
Arielle Hersh
02:24:36
thank you to our interpreters Jacky and Ruben!!
Pamela Herrera
02:24:40
Thank you!
Elise, New Economy Project
02:24:45
join us in Albany March 9th! https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdSud4laU4idL7VthMcchrs9SFNDeL3-9nmVSlp39eFvtbbAw/viewform
Interpreter Ruben Martinez
02:24:50
and flor
Samelys Lopez
02:25:03
thank you everyone!
Interpreter Ruben Martinez
02:25:11
Thank you Evy
Interpreter Ruben Martinez
02:25:15
!
Gary Simon
02:25:27
Goodnight everyone!
Deborah Scott-Gonzalez
02:25:28
Thank you Evy
Sabrina Bazile (they/sabrina | black homeownership project)
02:25:28
thank you!!
Chelle BloomXX
02:25:33
thank you very much
Anna Vincenty
02:25:36
great meeting!!!
Athena Bernkopf
02:25:38
thanks so much y'all
Chelle BloomXX
02:25:47
All of you!
Marcela Mitaynes
02:26:09
Gov number (518) 474-8390
Carlos Ronisky
02:26:32
Thanks all!
INTERPRETE(R). Flor Lopez (she/ella,her)
02:26:52
Bye. Thank you!